In a recent piece for The Dial, a college professor teaching Canadian politics draws a sharp parallel between modern generative AI and Jonathan Swift’s 1726 satire, Gulliver’s Travels. As the work turns 300 this year, the author argues that Swift’s depiction of the 'Engine' at the Grand Academy of Lagado—which allowed the 'most ignorant person' to write books without study—foreshadowed the current educational crisis. The professor, who battles to keep AI out of his classrooms, views LLMs not as productivity tools but as engines of 'speculative learning' that erode the friction necessary for intellectual growth.
The Lagado Engine vs. Large Language Models
The article highlights a specific passage where Gulliver witnesses a massive wooden contraption requiring 40 individuals to rotate iron handles, assembling word fragments into sentences for a scribe. The professor identifies this as a direct precursor to the 'autocomplete' nature of LLMs, noting the hidden human labor behind the seemingly lean digital interface. He argues that, like the scientists in Laputa who extract sunbeams from cucumbers, modern AI adoption in education is often a 'solution in search of a problem,' driven by a blind faith in technological inevitability rather than pedagogical necessity.
The Cost of Cognitive Offloading
Citing a Brookings Institution report, the author notes that while AI offers benefits for students with disabilities, the risks of dependence currently outweigh them. Students are described as 'training themselves daily to surrender their capacity for focus, reason, creativity and problem-solving.' The professor recounts the 'dark temptation' to let students submit AI-generated 'slop' and then use ChatGPT to grade it, resulting in a cycle of 'fake feedback for a fake assignment.' This mirrors the Soviet joke: 'We pretend to work and they pretend to pay us.'
Building a Digital Citadel
In response to rampant distraction and AI use, the professor has instituted a strict ban on phones and laptops, reverting to 'chalk and talk' to prevent his teaching materials from training rival models. This approach has yielded mixed results; while some students resist, others acknowledge the benefits of a tech-free space. The author also shares an anecdote about a student who made $8,000 trading the 'shitcoin' $MELANIA during a lecture on Quebec sovereignty, illustrating the 'abject desolation' of competing with speculative gambling for student attention.
Key Takeaways
- The professor views AI detectors as unreliable, noting students use services to 'humanify' AI text, leading to false accusations.
- Swift’s concept of 'flappers'—servants who rattle devices to snap thinkers out of abstraction—is compared to smartphone addiction.
- The author fears being labeled an 'enemy of the future' by tech evangelists, a term used by theorist Jathan Sadowski.
- Despite the backlash against AI boosterism at university commencements, the professor maintains a 'duty of care' to halt attention decay.
The Bottom Line
While tech evangelists promise revolution, this educator’s return to analog methods suggests that the most effective tool against AI-induced intellectual atrophy is the simple, unavoidable friction of human effort.