For builders and educators, the integration of AI into daily workflows mirrors a historic shift in education. Economist Daniel Susskind, author of What Should My Children Do? A Human’s Guide to the Age of AI, suggests that the current panic over AI in schools is misplaced. Speaking to RNZ’s Afternoons, Susskind argues that the goal is not to reject new tools, but to structure learning so that fundamental building blocks remain secure while leveraging technological efficiency.
The Calculator Model for AI Integration
Susskind draws a direct parallel between today’s AI debates and the introduction of the calculator. He notes that fears of 'de-enumeration' were rampant then, just as fears of cognitive atrophy are present now. The solution adopted was not to ban calculators, but to split the curriculum. Students spent half their time using calculators for complex tasks and the other half without them. This dual-track approach ensures that basic numeracy remains intact while allowing efficiency gains from tools. Susskind advocates for a similar split in AI education, where students learn to use AI for advanced tasks but maintain literacy, numeracy, and critical thinking skills manually.
Beyond the Screen Time Debate
The discussion around AI in schools often falls into binary camps of optimists versus pessimists. Susskind rejects this framing, labeling it as unhelpful. He argues that parents are wasting energy searching for a 'Goldilocks level of screen time.' The real debate should focus on the content of those screens, not the duration. Susskind maintains that putting up barriers and accusing young people of cheating was the wrong approach. Instead, he advocates for a curriculum reform that explicitly addresses technological distraction, ensuring the next generation understands the risks and has the tools to respond to them.
Social Media Restrictions vs. Technological Conservatism
Susskind supports 'well-informed restrictions' on social media for young people, acknowledging the specific harms of these platforms. However, he warns that concerns about social media should not seep into 'general technological conservatism.' He argues that preparing children for the world parents grew up in, rather than the world they will live in, is a failure of imagination. It ignores how these technologies can help the next generation understand problems and solve ideas. The key is distinguishing between the specific risks of social media and the broader utility of AI tools.
Why 'Suits' and 'House' Are Bad Career Advice
For those entering the workforce, Susskind describes asking 'what jobs are safe' as a 'diminishingly useful' question. He cites specific examples of how media distorts job expectations: going into law because of the show Suits, or medicine because of House, will leave young people 'bitterly disappointed.' This is not just because life is nothing like Hollywood, but because technology is going to change these jobs 'beyond recognition.' The specific roles will vanish, but the underlying problems—providing access to justice, making people live healthier, longer lives—will remain.
The Hybrid Skill Set of the Future
Susskind’s advice to young people wanting to go into these careers is to take the traditional route. In domains like law and medicine, success requires a combination of great technical expertise and a huge amount of domain expertise. People need to know what a legal problem actually looks like, not just how to operate a tool. He advises being far more open-minded and agnostic about particular job titles, focusing instead on the problems they enjoy solving. This mix of deep domain knowledge and technical skill is what AI alone cannot replicate.
Key Takeaways
- Split curricula into AI-assisted and manual segments to preserve fundamental skills like literacy and numeracy.
- Focus on the content of screen time rather than debating total duration or implementing blanket bans.
- Apply 'well-informed restrictions' to social media, but avoid general technological conservatism regarding AI tools.
- Avoid choosing careers based on Hollywood portrayals like Suits or House; focus on solving enduring problems with hybrid technical and domain expertise.
The Bottom Line
Builders need to stop treating AI as a magic bullet or a threat. The calculator model proves that we can integrate powerful tools without losing our core competencies, provided we structure our learning environments with intention. The 'back to basics' approach isn't about rejecting technology; it's about ensuring we understand the underlying logic before letting the black box handle the heavy lifting.